Defenders
Many of the articles, comments and posts over the summer included the assertion that Arsenal had to strengthen the defence. I’m not convinced that there is a big problem there and the Flamini addition gives us more options. As a four Gibbs, Monreal, Sagna and Jenkinson provide good starters and cover at full back. At least for the left back slot there is real competition for the position.
Our defence, like any defence is at its best when the midfield provides good cover. Arteta is a master in that role and Flamini is fine cover.
Left Back
Monreal joined at a point where Gibbs future looked pretty unclear. With injuries and inconsistency his long term future with the club seemed less than rosy. Monreal came in and looked really solid, a good passer and consistent. Gibbs has reacted really well and to my mind has lifted his game since Monreal’s arrival. I thought he would be relegated to second choice.
Gibbs is a highly mobile player who can intercept high up the pitch, but who is often let down by his passing. He has improved in this area and we look well set. Monreal reads the game very well defensively, but lacks that mobility. His passing is controlled and usually accurate, but he lacks that impressive burst of pace. I think we’re very well set here.
Right Back
Within a few months of Bacary Sagna joining we realised we had a very solid, high quality full back. He has earned a place in the Premiership team of the year and in spite of injuries has performed very well. He has had some drops in form and there was doubt about him staying. He seems more settled now and is a key part of our back four. I’m not as convinced as M. Wenger with him at centre back, but with TV5 returning, he’ll play there less often.
Carl Jenkinson arrived at Arsenal via an unusual route and appears to be growing from playing around better players. He’s hard working and committed, but there are still doubts there. His passing can be quite wayward and his reading of the game is improving, rather than at the top level. I am still not totally convinced that Jenkinson will be with us in a few years time, but I’d love to be proved wrong. If Sagna was injured for a big game and Arteta fit I wonder if Wenger would be tempted to put Flamini in.
Centre Back
The area that attracted the most attention and with rumoured interest in Williams it looked as if we might strengthen. Williams looks a solid player, reasonably mobile with okay distribution. I am not sure he’d be the first choice if we did buy him. We all know the strengths and weaknesses of Kolscieny and Mertesacker. Mobility Vs intelligence, Pace vs Judgement? The compliment each other well in my opinion and they look to be our natural choice.
Vermaelen needs to have a good season when he gets a chance. He made a lot of individual errors last season and looks a long way from the dynamic, strong and consistent centre back and leader we thought we had. Is it confidence? I have no idea, but I still believe Thomas can have a really good career with us, but then again I am an ostrich. I’d love to see him really pushing for a starting position.
On balance I think we are pretty well set in defence, particularly now that Vermaelen is fit again.